Playing now

Dual Loyalty? | Rabbi Elie Mischel on American Jews, Israel, and Redemption

49:57 Min. Listen

May 27, 2026

On this episode of Shoulder to Shoulder, Pastor Doug Reed and Rabbi Pesach Wolicki welcome Rabbi Elie Mischel to discuss his provocative new book, Countdown: American Jews and God’s Plan for Redemption.

At the center of the conversation is one of the most uncomfortable questions in modern Jewish life: the issue of “dual loyalty.” Can Jews fully belong to America while remaining faithful to the Jewish mission centered in Israel? And what happens when rising antisemitism forces that question into the open?

Rabbi Mischel makes the controversial argument that Judaism is not fundamentally a religion at all, but a nationhood rooted in the Bible, the Land of Israel, and a collective historical destiny. Drawing on the stories of Abraham, the Exodus, and the Book of Esther, he argues that many American Jews are confronting the same identity crisis faced by Persian Jewry thousands of years ago: are they Americans who happen to be Jewish, or Jews temporarily living in America?

The discussion explores Zionism, assimilation, exile, redemption, Tucker Carlson, the modern accusation of dual loyalty, and why Rabbi Mischel believes the current moment may be a turning point for the future of American Jewry. The episode also examines the growing crisis of biblical literacy among both Jews and Christians, and why recovering the Hebrew Bible is essential for understanding Israel and the moral struggles of our time.

Check out The Israel Bible YouTube channel.

Join Doug and his family as they prepare to move to Israel by watching The Reeds Are Here on YouTube.

Watch Shoulder to Shoulder along with Pesach’s other fantastic content on his YouTube channel.

Related Podcasts

The Strange Alliance Against America and Israel: Dr. James Lindsay on Dugin, Russia, and the New Right

49:50

June 3, 2026

Shavuot and Pentecost: Two Distinct Holy Days, One Shared Language of Responsibility

40:08

May 20, 2026

Can Catholics Be Zionists? Dr. Andre Villeneuve on Israel, the Church, and God’s Covenant

45:36

May 13, 2026

A Time for Choosing: Faith, Israel, and a Defining Moment in Washington

36:31

May 6, 2026

Erin Molan: Why I Chose to Stand with Israel

40:48

April 29, 2026

Dinesh D’Souza on Israel, Faith, and the Collapse of Trust in the West

39:37

April 23, 2026