Why Israel’s Enemies Hate Cartology

January 20, 2025

4 min read

Israel Country is push pinned on world map close up zoom photo with high resolution (Source: Shutterstock)

Moshe Phillips is national chairman of Americans For A Safe Israel (www.AFSI.org), a leading pro-Israel advocacy and education organization.

Israel’s enemies hate cartology, the study of mapmaking—as we were reminded again last week in the commotion over a map of biblical Israel.

Some Israel-hater noticed that the X (Twitter) account of the Israeli Foreign Ministry included a map showing the biblical borders of the ancient kingdoms of Judea and Israel, including the parts that extended eastward across the Jordan River.

The text asks, “Did you know that the Kingdom of Israel was established 3000 years ago?” The answer is that, unfortunately, most people did not know that—because the facts about the boundaries of the Land of Israel are one of those topics that mainstream media outlets and left leaning professors never talk about.

The text also mentions King David, King Solomon, and other personalities and events from the biblical period. The Washington Post and the history faculty at Columbia University don’t like talking about them, for good reason—because they remind us that Israel’s roots in the Holy Land are deep and strong, reaching back literally thousands of years.

he Foreign Ministry post concludes with another simple statement of fact: “The Jewish people in the Diaspora continued to look forward to the revival of their powers and capabilities and the rebuilding of their state, which was declared in the State of Israel in 1948 to become the only democracy in the Middle East.”

Hysterical comments about the map quickly erupted across the Arab world.

Jordanian leaders were especially overheated in their response. Jordan’s foreign ministry said it “condemns in the strongest terms the maps of the region” posted by the Israelis, because they include territories which they “claim are historical for Israel, including parts of the occupied Palestinian territories, the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria.”

Those maps are “racist,” the Jordanians added, using what is fast becoming the most overused word in the English language used to attack Israel. Actually, the maps are exactly the opposite of racism, since Israel is a multi-racial state in which all groups are treated equally, by contrast with the Arab world, where blacks are victims of genocide (Sudan), are enslaved (Mauritania), and are massacred if they even approach the border in the hope of entering (Saudi Arabia).

Moreover, Israel does not have a law mandating the death penalty for selling land to members of a particular ethnic group, but the Palestinian Authority does—and that group is the Jews.

President Reuven Rivlin hosts policewomen from the Arab sector, with the Police Chief Roni Alsheikh, at the President’s residence in Jerusalem, on June 20, 2018. Photo by Hadas Parush/Flash90

The speaker of the Jordanian parliament, Ahmad al-Safadi, said the maps “express a criminal mentality and malicious ambitions that cannot be ignored or tolerated.”

Not to be outdone, the Palestinian Authority declared that it rejects “alleged maps of historical Israel that include Arab lands.” Official PA spokesman Nabil Abu Rudeineh blasted the “alleged map with a comment fabricating an Israeli history dating back thousands of years in line with the Hebrew allegations.”

According to Abu Rudeineh, “this behavior constitutes a flagrant violation of all international legitimacy resolutions and international law.” If that were the case, of course, every copy of the Bible would have to be confiscated or destroyed, since it is chock full of references to the ancient borders of the Land of Israel.

The Palestinian Arab writer Yaseen Izeddeen expressed outrage that “the current rulers of Israel declare that Jordan is part of the Land of Israel, and these are old positions that go back more than a hundred years.”

Izeddeen may have been referring to the fact that it was just over one hundred years ago that the British authorities in Mandatory Palestine sliced the country in two and turned most of it into the artificial country of “Jordan.”

The year was 1922. The British colonialists needed to give Abdullah bin Al-Hussein a “country” to rule over, after they had disappointed him by giving the throne of Iraq to his brother. So, they severed the eastern 78% of Palestine and handed it to him on a silver platter as a consolation prize, dubbing it “Transjordan.”

Abdullah posing with British officials and his entourage on 28 March 1921 in front of the British Government House in Jerusalem. (Credit: Wikipedia)

They picked that name not because the people living there were ethnically “Trans-Jordanian.” They were no such thing. They were no different from the Arabs living on the western side of the Jordan. They called it “Trans-Jordan” because that means “the other side of the Jordan.”

The very fact that its name is based on a negative—that it’s not on That Side of the river—instead of on something having to do with the actual identity of its residents, illustrates how phony the country’s creation was.

Later on, Abdullah and his tribe, the Hashemites, decided to change the name again in order to reinforce their dictatorial rule. So it became “the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.” Again, the arbitrary changing of its name shows how inauthentic the country was, and is.

No wonder all these Jordanian and Palestinian Arab spokesmen are furious about last week’s posting of a map that reminds the public of Israel’s ancient borders.

They don’t want the public to know that Jordan is an artificial entity, that “Palestinian” identity was invented to undermine the Jews, and that Jews ruled the Land of Israel for countless centuries. The facts of Middle East cartology are politically very inconvenient.

VOTE NOW TO STOP A PALESTINIAN STATE

JOIN MORE THAN

5092

registered voters!

If you would like to stop the threat of a Palestinian State in the heartland of Israel, vote for Israel365 in the upcoming World Zionist Congress elections taking place from now until May 4, 2025. Please submit your information to learn how YOU can STOP the TWO STATE delusion!
* To be eligible to vote you must be a Jewish US citizen who is 18+ with primary residency in the US.

Share this article

Subscribe

Prophecy from the Bible is revealing itself as we speak. Israel365 News is the only media outlet reporting on it.

Sign up to our free daily newsletter today to get all the most important stories directly to your inbox. See how the latest updates in Jerusalem and the world are connected to the prophecies we read in the Bible. .